Fire and Knives – issue 6

So, I’ve written another piece for the wonderful Fire and Knives food quarterly. It’s on the subject of Halal and Kosher slaughter, and sadly the following conclusion didn’t quite make it to print:

“…Kosher and Halal. Two words you’ll rarely if ever, see in a Michelin starred restaurant or a farmer’s market, but with a growing global population of Muslims and with around 18 million Jews worldwide, they’re deeply relevant ones. In this world of endless racism, fear, ignorance and rabid wall-building between one another, surely it’s more vital than ever that we emphasise our commonality and remember our humanity- and what better place to start than with the food on our plates?

The main similarities between these Abrahamic religions are only partially down to the semantics of slaughter. Like so many aspects of modern life, too much emphasis has been placed on their outward appearance and ritual. Ultimately it’s all about the purity and integrity at the core of these laws, for these are so much more than mere restrictive rules; they can in fact be viewed as a clarion call to holiness. By imposing strict rules upon what can and cannot be eaten, a strong sense of self control is inculcated, which in turn helps to rein in our most basic and primal instincts. By being gentle with our beasts we reinforce the very things which keep us from becoming like them. In “to be a Jew” Rabbi Hayim Halevy Donin states that it’s about being able to tell the difference between right and wrong, good and evil, the sacred and the profane. The Qur’anic reasons for banning carrion and blood and “the animal that has been strangled or beaten to death or gored to death or savaged by a beast of prey..” are not just about the health of the consumer and the consumed. They’re designed to emphasise the “good” and the “pure” rather than the casually violent. It’s about minimising the pain of the eaten and increasing the responsibility of the eater. Cleanliness, integrity and self restraint, proper animal welfare and respectful slaughter – these are the real messages here and in advocating them, eating becomes the ultimate act of worship.”

You can subscribe to Fire and Knives here.


  1. Foodie

    Honestly, what a load of drivel. Perhaps you should have had a read of this before using the terms “proper animal welfare” and “respectful slaughter” in an article about halal.

  2. gastrogeek

    Oh dear, I’m so sorry you feel that way.

    I interviewed proper experts in the industry and read things like this
    I don’t mean to offend you, but perhaps it might be worth you reading the whole piece properly? I’d really recommend subscribing (you can get a whole year for just £32) 🙂

  3. EdGould

    It does make me laugh when people leave derisory comments without really getting the point. Have you read the whole article ‘Foodie’? Its clearly about the surprising similarity in the religion’s intentions, not an investigation into how these intentions are executed (pardon the pun).

  4. As this is clearly an addendum of sorts to a full article published elsewhere, it seems rather unfair to make a sweeping (and extremely rudely expressed) statement on the article as a whole?

    Some people seem simply to be looking for reasons to take offence…

  5. gastrogeek

    Cheers Kavey, I really appreciate it and unfortunately yes, it’s a shame that some people just seem to want to have a dig…(it was a bit rude wasn’t it?!)

  6. Interesting idea, going to go and have a read ^_^

  7. Where it says subscribe here, the link is broken (on Chrome anyway).

  8. gastrogeek

    thanks Sasa, I think it might be a problem with the f&k website, as even the home page doesn’t seem to be working….(you can borrow my copy in the meantime if you like? email me at

  9. SimonTeatime

    great peice – i subscribe to F@K and love the fact that you often venture beyond the usual stomping ground of food writing into contentious topics like this. Keep it coming!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: